Ahoy there, fellow adventurers! The Pirates of the Caribbean series, with its thrilling escapades, supernatural twists, and the unforgettable Captain Jack Sparrow, has left an indelible mark on moviegoers worldwide. Yet, even in the vast sea of storytelling, there are hidden depths where plot holes lie in wait.
Let’s embark on the Black Pearl and delve into the 10 biggest plot holes scattered across all five Pirates of the Caribbean movies. From cursed treasures to mystical compasses, we’ll scrutinize these cinematic waters to uncover the inconsistencies that may have slipped through the cracks.
The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003) Plot Holes:
a. Endless Night or Just a Weekend?: In the first adventure, “Curse of the Black Pearl,” Captain Hector Barbossa and his cursed crew are condemned to an immortal existence under the moonlight due to Aztec gold.
However, the moonlight curse seems to have a mind of its own. At times, it appears to last indefinitely, while in other scenes, it’s as fleeting as a weekend getaway. The inconsistency in the curse’s duration raises questions about the rules that govern the undead crew.
b. Barbossa’s Apple Nonsense: Barbossa’s peculiar habit of eating apples is a character quirk that’s hard to miss. However, it’s later revealed that the cursed crew can’t taste or enjoy anything, rendering Barbossa’s apple consumption a perplexing enigma. The contradiction between his undead state and his indulgence in mundane activities creates a plot hole that leaves audiences scratching their heads.
Dead Man’s Chest (2006): Davy Jones’ Contradictions about Plot Holes:
a. The Heart’s Compass Woes: Davy Jones, the tentacled captain of the Flying Dutchman, is bound by the heart within the Dead Man’s Chest. However, the plot takes an unexpected turn when Jack Sparrow steals the heart and uses it as a bargaining chip. If Jones’ heart controls him, why is he still able to exert control over the Flying Dutchman after Jack has possession of it? This inconsistency in the heart’s power creates a tangled web of confusion.
Read More
Aquaman 2 might clash with Salaar and Dunki
b. Bootstrap Bill’s Reckoning:Bootstrap Bill Turner, a key character in “Dead Man’s Chest,” has a bone to pick with Jack Sparrow for leaving him to the mercy of the Kraken. However, Bootstrap seems surprisingly coherent and self-aware for someone who has spent a considerable amount of time as part of the Flying Dutchman’s crew. The discrepancy in Bootstrap’s mental state raises questions about the long-term effects of serving on the cursed ship.
At World’s End (2007): The Maelstrom Muddle:
a. The Maelstrom’s Time Warp: “At World’s End” introduces the breathtaking Maelstrom, a swirling vortex that becomes the backdrop for an epic naval battle. However, the timeline of events during this sequence seems to exist in its own nautical dimension. Characters miraculously appear and disappear at improbable intervals, leaving audiences bewildered about the physics of the Maelstrom and the characters’ uncanny ability to navigate its chaotic currents
.b. Calypso’s Confounding Powers: Calypso, the sea goddess, plays a pivotal role in the plot, and her powers are as enigmatic as the depths of the ocean. Her ability to manipulate the elements and control the sea raises the question: Why doesn’t she use her formidable powers earlier in the series to aid or thwart the characters? The inconsistency in Calypso’s involvement leaves a void in the narrative that remains uncharted.
On Stranger Tides (2011): Fountain of Youth Conundrums:
a. Barbossa’s Cursed Resilience: “On Stranger Tides” introduces the quest for the Fountain of Youth, and once again, Captain Barbossa finds himself in the crosshairs of supernatural elements. However, Barbossa’s resilience to the curse is baffling. How does he manage to break free from the curse just by having a bit of the Black Pearl in a bottle? The lack of clarity surrounding the curse’s parameters leaves this plot hole hanging in the Caribbean breeze.
b. Jack Sparrow’s Compass Capers: Jack Sparrow’s magical compass has been a guiding force throughout the series, pointing the way to what the beholder wants most. However, in “On Stranger Tides,” Jack seems strangely ignorant of how to use his own compass. This inconsistency in Jack’s relationship with the compass raises questions about its reliability and the rules governing its magical properties.
Dead Men Tell No Tales (2017): The Phantom Pirates Paradox:
a. Salazar’s Supernatural Rule-Bending: Captain Armando Salazar and his crew, trapped in the Devil’s Triangle, are cursed specters seeking revenge. However, the rules governing their supernatural existence seem to shift as per the convenience of the plot.
At times, they can’t set foot on land, and at other times, they materialize effortlessly. The inconsistency in the rules governing Salazar and his crew creates a phantom paradox that haunts the narrative.
b. Will Turner’s Time Management:The post-credits scene of “Dead Men Tell No Tales” shows Will Turner reuniting with Elizabeth Swan after breaking his curse by taking over the Flying Dutchman. However, the timeline of events is puzzling.
If Will Turner was freed from the curse, why did he look like a barnacle-encrusted sailor when he returned to Elizabeth? The temporal tangle in Will Turner’s timeline becomes a puzzling plot hole.
Conclusion:
As we sail the tempestuous seas of Pirates of the Caribbean, it’s evident that even the most captivating tales harbor uncharted waters filled with plot holes. The saga of Captain Jack Sparrow, cursed treasures, and supernatural entities may have enthralled audiences, but these inconsistencies serve as reminders that every cinematic voyage has its hidden reefs.
Whether it’s the intricacies of curses, the enigma of magical compasses, or the paradoxes of supernatural beings, the Pirates of the Caribbean series leaves us with a legacy of unanswered questions and uncharted mysteries. As we bid adieu to the high seas, let’s acknowledge the plot holes that, like buried treasures, add a touch of intrigue to the legacy of these cinematic adventures.
Share this content: